This is a list of deaths in some apparent order.
2001[]
- Harris Antonini
- Joshua Aiken - killed in an explosion at the marina
- Randall Martin - killed by a head spade
- Christopher Cullen - impaled by a head spade and hung at the Tree of Woe
- Sarah Mills - discovered hung at the Tree of Woe
- Kate Seaver - discovered hung at the Tree of Woe
Between 2001 and 2008[]
- Frank Dunn
- Victims of the Wakefield Copycat
- Cody - injured after the accident on State Route 530 and was beaten to death by Wakefield.
- Ashley - injured after the accident on State Route 530 and was killed by Wakefield.
- Peck - injured after the accident on State Route 530 died in an explosion set by Wakefield.
2008[]
- Ben Wellington - dismembered by the propeller
- Marty Dunn - cut in half on the bridge
- Reverend Fain - decapitated by a head spade
- Kelly Seaver - discovered hung at home
- Lucy Daramour - lit on fire
- Hunter Jennings - shot in the head by a shotgun trap
- Joel Booth - accidentally shot himself in the leg
- Thomas Wellington - impaled by a head spade trap
- Andrew Cullen - disemboweled
- Richard Allen - killed by a harpoon to the chest
- Sparky Mackle - discovered murdered at home
- Malcolm Ross - chopped to body parts
- Deputy Garrett - shot in the back
- Cole Harkin - killed by an arrow to his heart
- Unknown Woman
- Brent Cyr - discovered floating in a pool
- J.D. Dunn - bleeds to death of stomach wounds
- Beth Barrington - top half discovered in a crawlspace
- Katherine Wellington - stabbed in the back by pruning shears
- Darryl Riggens - shot by a shooter disguised as the sheriff
- Tyra Coulter - shot by a shooter disguised as the sheriff
- Maggie Krell - hung from the roof of The Cannery
- Charlie Mills - hung by Wakefield
- Nikki Bolton - stabbed by Wakefield
- Shane Pierce - stabbed in a fight with Wakefield
- Patrick Lillis - discovered with his throat slit
- Cal Vandeusen - stabbed by Wakefield
- Chloe Carter - deliberately lets go of the hand rail and jumps from the bridge into the water after Cal's murder.
- Danny Brooks - impaled in the eye with a memo holder by Wakefield
- Trish Wellington - stabbed in the stomach by Henry
- Christopher Sullivan - stabbed in the back by Henry
- John Wakefield - stabbed and betrayed by his son and accomplice, Henry
- Henry Dunn - stabbed by Abby with a boarding knife.